How a demand is raised continues to decide whether it survives. This digest groups 12 rulings added in November 2026 on the conditions for invoking section 74, notices and orders that do not state grounds, demands confirmed on new grounds, tax paid under the wrong head, and two significant classification and valuation disputes, with an earlier contrary ruling on SUV cess for comparison.
Each heading links to our detailed posts.
Key trends from these rulings
- Section 74 requires intent to evade, shown by foundational facts in the notice. Omission in GSTR-3B, payment after audit, a legal dispute or a supplier's retrospective cancellation is not enough (Needs Manpower, Jaipur Development Authority, Priya Gupta, Sain Medicaments). Where section 74 fails, section 75(2) can let the officer proceed under section 73 if within time (Priya Gupta).
- A demand must rest on a proper notice stating grounds. A DRC-01 summary is not a show cause notice (Fortinet), and orders cannot be confirmed on grounds never put to the taxpayer (Josco Gold, Meera Associates).
- Tax paid under CGST/SGST instead of IGST is not short payment; the amount should be transferred or set off (DHR Holding, Sunil Steels).
- No scrutiny or audit is needed before a section 73 notice, but a GSTR-1 vs GSTR-3B gap must be tested against the taxpayer's explanation (Radikan Engineers).
- GSTAT benches now differ on SUV cess before 26.07.2023: Bengaluru applied the laden measure (Advaith Motors), Lucknow the unladen one (Natasha Automobiles).
Section 74 and intent to evade
- Rajasthan HC - Jaipur Development Authority: Section 74 notice of about Rs 73 crore quashed: intent to evade is a jurisdictional fact, and non-payment or a legal dispute is not enough.
- GSTAT Bengaluru - Needs Manpower Support Services: GSTAT Bengaluru held omission in GSTR-3B and payment after audit do not prove suppression; Section 74 penalty set aside following Tata Steel.
- GSTAT Cuttack - Priya Gupta: Section 74 notice based only on a supplier's retrospective cancellation held invalid but deemed a Section 73 notice for fresh decision.
- GSTAT Hyderabad - Sain Medicaments: TRAN credit allowed despite an ER-1 missed due to a portal glitch; Section 74 not made out and penalty beyond the notice set aside.
Notices, grounds and natural justice
- GSTAT Bengaluru - Fortinet Technologies: Demand based only on a DRC-01 summary, without a show cause notice or hearing, quashed; new grounds in first appeal not allowed.
- GSTAT Thiruvananthapuram - Josco Gold: Demand confirmed on grounds not in the show cause notice and without a hearing violates Sections 75(7) and 75(4).
- GSTAT Hyderabad - Meera Associates: Non-speaking order that wrongly said no documents were filed set aside; rail transport of hatching eggs may be exempt under Notification 12/2017.
- GSTAT Bengaluru - Radikan Engineers: No ASMT-10 or audit needed before a Section 73 notice, but a GSTR-1 vs GSTR-3B gap caused by duplicate reporting is not taxable.
Tax paid under the wrong head
- Bombay HC - DHR Holding India: Rs 7.65 crore paid as CGST/SGST must be transferred to IGST, not demanded again; Section 74 needs intent to evade (Tata Steel).
- GSTAT Thiruvananthapuram - Sunil Steels: Tax paid under the wrong head is not short payment under Section 73; excess CGST/SGST set off against IGST due.
Classification and valuation
- GSTAT Rajkot - Babu Lime: Chuna in slurry and paste form is slaked lime under 2522 20 00 at 5%, not a food preparation under 2106 at 18%.
- GSTAT Bengaluru - Advaith Motors: Rs 9.76 crore SUV cess demand set aside: ground clearance measured laden before 26.07.2023, per Circular 247/04/2025.
- GSTAT Lucknow - Natasha Automobiles: Earlier contrary view: GSTAT Lucknow applied the unladen measure even before 26.07.2023 and restored a Rs 25.66 lakh cess demand.
What businesses should do now
- Read every section 74 notice for specific facts of intent to evade; challenge mechanical recitals relying on Tata Steel.
- If only a DRC-01 summary is received, object in writing that no valid notice has been issued.
- Compare the order with the notice and challenge any new ground under section 75(7).
- Where tax was paid under the wrong head, ask for transfer or set-off rather than paying again.
Frequently asked questions
Is non-payment of tax enough to invoke section 74?
No. The Rajasthan High Court held intent to evade is a jurisdictional fact that must appear from the notice.
Is IGST paid as CGST/SGST treated as unpaid?
The Bombay High Court and GSTAT Thiruvananthapuram held it is not short payment and should be transferred or set off.
Need help with a GST dispute?
GST Folio prepares replies to show cause notices, appeals before the Appellate Authority and GSTAT, refund claims and ITC reconciliations for businesses across India. Call or WhatsApp +91 80513 31315 or email gstfolio@zohomail.in. See also our GST litigation services.
This digest summarises judgments and orders added to our case law library in November 2026. Each linked post explains one ruling in more detail. It is general information, not legal advice; the outcome of any case depends on its own facts and the full text of the order.