Update dated 18 November 2026: The GST Appellate Tribunal, State Bench Hyderabad (Division Bench, Court II), in Appeal No. APL/240/HYD/2026 (Sain Medicaments Pvt Ltd vs Commissioner of Central Tax, Hyderabad), by order dated 30 October 2026, allowed transitional credit and set aside the Section 74 penalty.
🗣️ Saral bhasha mein samjhein
- Department ne TRAN credit isliye deny kiya ki pre-GST ka ek ER-1 return late file hua tha.
- Taxpayer ne pehle mauke par hi compliance kar di thi; deri technical/portal glitch ki wajah se thi jo uske control mein nahi tha.
- Tribunal: substantive compliance ho gayi to strict literal timeline par zid galat hai – credit allowed.
- SCN mein Section 122(2)(a) penalty prastavit thi, par order mein Section 74 r/w 122(2)(b) laga di – notice se bahar jaana galat.
- Fraud, wilful misstatement ya suppression sabit nahi – Section 74 ka sawal hi nahi.
📲 Sawal hai? WhatsApp karein: 8051331315
Facts
Sain Medicaments carried forward transitional credit into GST. The department disallowed it, citing the belated filing of one ER-1 return under the old law, and imposed penalty under Section 74 read with Section 122(2)(b). The first appellate authority upheld the order. The taxpayer said the delay was caused by technical glitches beyond its control and that it complied at the first opportunity.
Issue
Whether transitional credit can be denied for delayed procedural compliance caused by portal problems, and whether Section 74 and penalty under Section 122(2)(b) could be imposed when the notice proposed Section 122(2)(a).
Held / Ruling
- Both the adjudication order and the appellate order travelled beyond the notice by imposing penalty under Section 74 read with Section 122(2)(b) instead of Section 122(2)(a) as proposed.
- Substantive compliance, though belated, was made at the first opportunity despite glitches. The department's insistence on absolute, literal timelines was misdirected, so the transitional credit must be allowed.
- Fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression to take ineligible credit was not established. No mens rea can be attributed for one belated ER-1.
- The appellate order was set aside with consequential relief.
Key takeaways for taxpayers
- Keep screenshots, tickets and GSTN emails that prove portal glitches. They support claims of substantive compliance.
- Compare the penalty section in the order with the one proposed in the notice. Any change can be challenged.
Facing a similar GST dispute? See our GST litigation services or contact us.