📞 +91 80513 31315 ✉️ gstfolio@zohomail.in 🕘 Monday to Saturday, 10:00 am – 7:00 pm
Home › Blog › GSTAT Lucknow: Section 129 Penalty Only on Excess Undocumented Quanti…

GSTAT Lucknow: Section 129 Penalty Only on Excess Undocumented Quantity, Not Whole Consignment - Mani Ply

Update dated 18 November 2026: The GST Appellate Tribunal, State Bench Lucknow (Court I), in Appeal No. APL/239/LCK/2026 (State Tax vs M/s Mani Ply), by order dated 27 October 2026, dismissed the department's appeal and confirmed that Section 129 penalty applies only to the excess quantity not covered by documents.

🗣️ Saral bhasha mein samjhein

  • Transit mein gaadi rokne par 32 pieces documents se zyada mile.
  • Department ne poore consignment par Rs 57,870 penalty laga di thi.
  • First appellate authority ne sirf excess maal (lagbhag Rs 11,431, Rs 120 per sq m) par penalty tay ki aur baaki hata diya.
  • Tribunal ne kaha – baaki maal ke documents sahi the; sirf 32 extra pieces poore consignment par penalty ka aadhar nahi.
  • Order-in-Appeal No. 74 dated 28.06.2024 confirm.

📲 Sawal hai? WhatsApp karein: 8051331315

Facts

Goods of M/s Mani Ply, Lucknow were intercepted in transit and 32 pieces were found in excess of the quantity in the documents. Penalty of Rs 57,870 was imposed under Section 129 on the entire consignment. The Additional Commissioner Grade-II (Appeal)-4th, Lucknow, by Order-in-Appeal No. 74 dated 28 June 2024, separated the documented goods from the excess and limited the penalty to the excess quantity valued at about Rs 11,431. The State appealed.

Issue

Whether Section 129 penalty should be computed on the entire consignment or only on the undocumented excess quantity.

Held / Ruling

  • The first appellate authority took a reasoned approach by distinguishing the documented quantity from the excess.
  • The department showed no error in identifying documented and undocumented quantities, and no evidence about the rest of the goods.
  • Detection of 32 excess pieces does not justify penalty on the whole consignment. The departmental appeal was dismissed.

Key takeaways for taxpayers

  • If only part of a consignment is undocumented, argue that Section 129 penalty must be limited to that part.
  • Insist that the detention record clearly separates the quantity covered by invoice and e-way bill.

Goods detained or penalised under Section 129? See our GST litigation services or contact us.

Need help? Call/WhatsApp +91 80513 31315 or email gstfolio@zohomail.in.

Need help with GST or Income Tax?

Registration, monthly returns, ITR and GST notices, handled online by experts since 2012.