Update dated 3 November 2026: The GST Appellate Tribunal, Bengaluru Bench (Division Bench, Court 3), in Appeal No. APL/126/BUR/2026 (M/s Radikan Engineers & Consultants vs Commissioner of Commercial Taxes, Karnataka), pronounced on 27 October 2026, rejected a jurisdiction challenge to a Section 73 notice but set aside the demand on merits. It held that a GSTR-1 vs GSTR-3B difference caused by one supply reported twice is not a taxable supply.
🗣️ Saral bhasha mein samjhein
- FY 2019-20 mein GSTR-1 ka tax GSTR-3B se zyada dikha, to Section 73 mein demand aayi – CGST Rs 1,11,540 + SGST Rs 1,11,540, interest aur Rs 11,154 penalty (each Act).
- Asal mein Rs 18,59,000 ki ek hi supply GSTR-1 mein do baar report ho gayi thi; tax December 2019 ke GSTR-3B mein bhar diya tha.
- Deductors ke GSTR-7 (jo department ke paas hi hain) ne ye sabit kiya – Tribunal ne poora demand Nil kar diya.
- Return amend na karne se galat entry "taxable supply" nahi ban jaati.
- Lekin jurisdiction plea reject hua – Section 73 notice ke liye pehle ASMT-10 (scrutiny) ya ADT-02 (audit) zaroori nahi.
📲 Sawal hai? WhatsApp karein: 8051331315
Facts
The appellant, a Bengaluru proprietorship, was issued a Section 73 order dated 6 August 2024 by the CTO (Audit)-4.7 for April 2019 to March 2020. The order covered two issues: a TDS turnover difference and a GSTR-1 vs GSTR-3B difference. The appellate authority allowed the first issue but confirmed the second on 3 February 2026. It rejected the explanation of a duplicate B2C entry because the return correction mechanism had not been used.
Issue
(i) Is a Section 73 proceeding without jurisdiction if no scrutiny under Section 61 or audit under Section 65 preceded it? (ii) Can tax be demanded merely because GSTR-1 shows more tax than GSTR-3B?
Arguments
The appellant argued that an Audit-wing officer could act under Section 73 only after an audit under Section 65(7). On merits, it said the excess was one supply of Rs 18,59,000 reported twice, as shown by the deductors' GSTR-7 returns. The Revenue defended the demand and sought further verification as an alternative.
Held / Ruling
- Section 73 is a self-contained power of determination. Scrutiny or audit is not a precondition, and Section 65(7) enables action rather than restricting it. The officer assigned the function under Section 2(91) had jurisdiction.
- Where a scrutiny or audit is in fact carried out, Rule 99 (ASMT-10) or Section 65(6) and Rule 101 must be followed. Their findings do not bind the adjudicating authority.
- A GSTR-1/3B difference is a valid basis for a notice and shifts the burden to explain. It is not conclusive proof of an extra supply.
- A specific, credible explanation must be tested against the Department's own records, and a reasoned finding recorded. Suspicion alone cannot sustain a demand.
- The demand, interest and penalty on Issue 2 were set aside. The Revenue's request for further verification was declined.
Key takeaways for taxpayers
- Reconcile GSTR-1 with GSTR-3B every month and amend wrong entries in time. It avoids disputes.
- If you missed the amendment window, back your explanation with third-party data such as GSTR-7, GSTR-2A/2B and invoices.
- Do not rely only on technical jurisdiction pleas against a Section 73 notice. Prepare the merits as well.
Mismatch notice received? See our GST litigation services and GST return filing service.