Update dated 19 November 2026: The GST Appellate Tribunal, Thiruvananthapuram Bench (Court I), in Appeal No. APL/40/TVP/2026 (Josco Gold Corporation Pvt Ltd vs Commissioner of Kerala SGST), by Final Order No. 20/TVP/KERALAM/2026 dated 5 November 2026, quashed a demand on sales-return credit notes for July 2017 to March 2018 because it was confirmed on grounds not stated in the show cause notice and without a personal hearing.
๐ฃ๏ธ Saral bhasha mein samjhein
- Jewellery company ne exchange par sales return dikhaye; SCN ka aarop tha โ "credit notes issue hi nahi kiye", Rs 2,10,892 short tax.
- Company ne credit notes ki list aur samples diye, baaki verification ke liye ready thi.
- Officer ne bina hearing, naye grounds par demand confirm ki โ value ka fark, same-day credit note.
- First appeal ne aur 4 naye grounds jod diye (Section 34 time limit, GSTR-9 mein na dikhna, etc.).
- Tribunal: Section 75(7) โ SCN ke bahar ke ground par demand nahi; Section 75(4) โ adverse order se pehle hearing zaroori. Dono orders null and void.
๐ฒ Sawal hai? WhatsApp karein: 8051331315
Facts
On scrutiny of returns for July 2017 to March 2018, the department alleged that Josco Gold had claimed sales returns without issuing credit notes, resulting in escaped turnover of Rs 70,29,725 and short payment of Rs 2,10,892. A Section 73 notice dated 28.09.2023 was followed by an order dated 29.12.2023 confirming the demand with interest and penalty. The appellant had filed a list and sample copies of credit notes and offered the full set for verification. The JC (Appeals), Kottayam, dismissed the appeal on 12.06.2025.
Issues
- Whether a demand can be confirmed on grounds not raised in the show cause notice.
- Whether an adverse order can be passed without a personal hearing.
- Whether the appellate authority can add new grounds under Section 107(11) without notice.
Held / Ruling
- The adjudicating authority relied on value differences and same-day issue of credit notes, which were never in the SCN or put to the appellant. This breached Section 75(7), which bars confirming a demand on grounds other than those in the notice.
- No personal hearing was held though an adverse decision was contemplated, violating Section 75(4).
- Having offered to produce all credit notes, the appellant cannot be blamed when the officer never called for them.
- Any further inquiry under Section 107(11) must follow natural justice. The first appellate authority's four new grounds were not based on any inquiry with notice. Following Armour Security (SC), both orders were quashed as null and void; the Revenue's plea that the Tribunal hearing cures the defect was rejected.
Key takeaways for taxpayers
- Check the order against the SCN line by line โ any new ground is a Section 75(7) violation.
- Always request a personal hearing in writing; denial of hearing under Section 75(4) vitiates the order.
- A taxpayer is entitled to a fair hearing at every stage โ a later Tribunal hearing does not cure earlier breaches.
Demand confirmed on new grounds or without hearing? See our GST litigation services or contact us.