Update dated 19 November 2026: The GST Appellate Tribunal, State Bench Hyderabad (Court I), in Appeal No. APL/16/HYD/2026 (M/s Meera Associates vs Deputy Commissioner (ST), Secunderabad), by order dated 27 October 2026, set aside a non-speaking demand order of Rs 50.47 lakh for FY 2017-18 and remanded the matter, holding that rail transport of hatching eggs may qualify for exemption under Notification No. 12/2017-Central Tax (Rate).
🗣️ Saral bhasha mein samjhein
- FY 2017-18 ke liye Rs 45.88 lakh tax aur Rs 4.58 lakh penalty ki demand thi.
- Officer aur first appeal dono ne kaha "koi document nahi diya" – jabki taxpayer ne GSTR-1, 3B, 9, turnover details aur railway circular sab jama kiye the.
- Tribunal ne kaha – bina reply aur evidence dekhe order dena non-speaking order hai, ye galat hai.
- Hatching eggs "agricultural produce" hain; inka rail transport S.No. 20, Notification 12/2017 ke under exempt ho sakta hai.
- Department ne khud FY 2021-22 mein yahi exemption de diya tha. Matter 8 hafte mein fresh decide hoga.
📲 Sawal hai? WhatsApp karein: 8051331315
Facts
M/s Meera Associates, Secunderabad, received a demand order dated 10 December 2024 for FY 2017-18 confirming tax of Rs 45,88,678 (CGST and SGST) and penalty of Rs 4,58,868 on outward supplies and ITC. The appellant claimed that its transport of hatching eggs by rail was exempt. The adjudicating authority and the first appellate authority rejected the claim, recording that no documentary evidence had been produced apart from a copy of Notification No. 12/2017.
Issues
- Whether an order passed without considering the reply and documents filed is sustainable.
- Whether rail transport of hatching eggs is eligible for exemption under S.No. 20 of Notification No. 12/2017-Central Tax (Rate) dated 28.06.2017.
Held / Ruling
- The record showed the appellant had filed GSTR-1, GSTR-3B, GSTR-9, month-wise taxable and exempt turnover, rail transport statements and the Railway Board Freight Marketing Circular No. 3 of 2019. The finding of "no evidence" was untrue.
- Relying on S.N. Mukherjee v. Union of India (1990) 4 SCC 594, a quasi-judicial order must record reasons. A non-speaking order that ignores the evidence cannot stand.
- Fresh eggs in shell are agricultural produce; transportation of agricultural produce by rail is unconditionally exempt under S.No. 20. The department had itself allowed this exemption for FY 2021-22 by order dated 29.11.2025.
- Following Share Medical Care v. UOI, exemption can be claimed even at a later stage. Order set aside; fresh order to be passed within eight weeks.
Key takeaways for taxpayers
- Keep acknowledgements of every reply and document filed – they defeat a "no evidence produced" finding.
- An exemption notification can be claimed in appeal even if not claimed in the return.
- Where the department has accepted an exemption for a later year, cite that order for earlier years.
Facing a GST demand order passed without considering your reply? See our GST litigation services or contact us.