📞 +91 80513 31315 ✉️ gstfolio@zohomail.in 🕘 Monday to Saturday, 10:00 am – 7:00 pm
Home › Blog › GSTAT Thane: GST Appeal Cannot Be Dismissed for Non-Prosecution, ITC …

GSTAT Thane: GST Appeal Cannot Be Dismissed for Non-Prosecution, ITC Demand on Cancelled Suppliers Remanded - Trivesh Enterprises

Update dated 19 November 2026: The GST Appellate Tribunal, State Bench Thane (Court I), in Appeal No. APL/53/THN/2026 (M/s Trivesh Enterprises LLP vs Joint Commissioner of State Tax, Thane/Kalyan), by order dated 22 October 2026, set aside ex-parte ITC demands and the appellate orders dismissing the appeals for non-prosecution, and remanded the matter for de novo adjudication.

🗣️ Saral bhasha mein samjhein

  • Suppliers ki registration ab-initio cancel hone par Rs 6,80,142 ITC aur Rs 68,016 penalty ki demand confirm ki gayi thi.
  • Original order mein koi reasoning nahi thi – sirf demand likh di gayi.
  • First appeal ko "non-prosecution" (hearing par na aane) ke kaaran dismiss kar diya gaya.
  • Tribunal ne kaha – Section 107(11) aur 107(12) ke under appellate authority ko merits par decide karna hi padega; non-prosecution par dismissal galat hai.
  • Sirf supplier ki retrospective cancellation ke aadhar par ITC demand confirm nahi ho sakti. Matter fresh hearing ke liye wapas.

📲 Sawal hai? WhatsApp karein: 8051331315

Facts

M/s Trivesh Enterprises LLP claimed ITC on purchases from suppliers whose registrations were later cancelled ab initio as non-functioning or non-existent. The Deputy Commissioner of State Tax, Bhiwandi-501, by orders dated 12.10.2023, confirmed the demands. The Joint Commissioner (Appeals), Kalyan, by orders dated 27/28.11.2025, upheld tax of Rs 6,80,142 and penalty of Rs 68,016, rejecting the appeals both on merits and for non-prosecution, holding that the appellant had not produced lorry receipts, e-way bills, stock registers or delivery proof to discharge the burden under Section 155.

Issues

  • Whether the adjudication orders, passed without reasons, were valid.
  • Whether a first appeal can be dismissed for non-prosecution.

Held / Ruling

  • The original orders confirmed substantial demands without independent analysis or findings on the transactions. Following Kranti Associates v. Masood Ahmed Khan (2010) 9 SCC 496, a quasi-judicial authority must pass a speaking order.
  • Section 107(11) and (12) require the Appellate Authority to decide the appeal on merits with points for determination and reasons. Relying on Purushottam Stores v. State of Bihar and Nav Nirman Construction (Patna HC), dismissal for non-prosecution is an abdication of statutory power.
  • The department cannot rely solely on retrospective cancellation of the supplier's registration without independent verification and a fair hearing.
  • All orders set aside; de novo adjudication with specific grounds, personal hearing and examination of evidence under Sections 16(2) and 155. The appellant must produce invoices, payment proof and proof of movement of goods.

Key takeaways for taxpayers

  • A GST first appeal cannot be thrown out merely because you missed a hearing – it must be decided on merits.
  • On remand, file complete proof: invoices, bank payments, e-way bills, transport documents and stock records.

ITC denied because your supplier's GSTIN was cancelled? See our GST litigation services or contact us.

Need help? Call/WhatsApp +91 80513 31315 or email gstfolio@zohomail.in.

Need help with GST or Income Tax?

Registration, monthly returns, ITR and GST notices, handled online by experts since 2012.