Detention of goods in transit and confiscation on survey remain common flashpoints. This digest covers four November 2026 GSTAT rulings that limited section 129 penalties and set aside section 130 confiscation based on stock differences.
Each entry links to the full post.
Key trends from these rulings
- Where only part of a consignment is undocumented, the section 129 penalty is limited to the excess goods (Mani Ply).
- A missing e-invoice is a matter for audit, not section 129, when a valid tax invoice and e-way bill accompany the goods; an out-of-State supplier must also be given a temporary ID before notices (Super Teck).
- Section 130 confiscation needs deliberate evasion. Stock estimated by eye, or a short delay in recording a genuine purchase, is not enough; tax is to be determined under sections 73/74 (Poorvi Enterprises, Time Steels).
Goods in transit (section 129)
- GSTAT Lucknow - Mani Ply: Section 129 penalty applies only to the undocumented excess quantity, not the entire consignment covered by valid documents.
- GSTAT Ernakulam - Super Teck Industries: No Section 129 penalty merely for a missing e-invoice when tax invoice and valid e-way bill accompany the goods; no temporary ID issued.
Stock differences and confiscation (section 130)
- GSTAT Lucknow - Poorvi Enterprises: Excess stock estimated by eye during inspection, without weighment or intent to evade, cannot lead to Section 130 confiscation.
- GSTAT Lucknow - Time Steels: GSTAT Lucknow held a two-day delay in recording genuine, invoiced stock is not non-accountal under Section 130; Rs 1.89 lakh demand stays deleted.
What businesses should do now
- Match quantities with the invoice and e-way bill before dispatch, and generate the IRN before movement if covered by e-invoicing.
- During a survey, insist on weighment and note objections to estimated quantities in the panchnama.
- Keep purchase invoices and bills of supply at the premises, even if book entries are pending.
- If detained in another State, check whether a temporary ID was generated before MOV-07 and MOV-09.
Frequently asked questions
Is the whole consignment penalised if some extra goods are found?
GSTAT Lucknow held the section 129 penalty applies only to the undocumented excess.
Can goods be confiscated just for excess stock?
GSTAT Lucknow, following the Allahabad High Court, held no; tax must be determined under sections 73 or 74.
Need help with a GST dispute?
GST Folio prepares replies to show cause notices, appeals before the Appellate Authority and GSTAT, refund claims and ITC reconciliations for businesses across India. Call or WhatsApp +91 80513 31315 or email gstfolio@zohomail.in. See also our GST litigation services.
This digest summarises judgments and orders added to our case law library in November 2026. Each linked post explains one ruling in more detail. It is general information, not legal advice; the outcome of any case depends on its own facts and the full text of the order.