Update dated 19 November 2026: The GST Appellate Tribunal, State Bench Lucknow (Court I), in Appeal No. APL/178/LCK/2026 (Assistant Commissioner, State Tax vs M/s Poorvi Enterprises), by order dated 2 November 2026, dismissed the department's appeal and held that excess stock found during inspection, estimated visually, cannot justify confiscation and penalty under Section 130.
π£οΈ Saral bhasha mein samjhein
- 16.05.2025 ki inspection mein 30,352 kg stainless steel bright bars aur 9,046 kg wires "excess" bataye gaye (value Rs 35.55 lakh).
- Section 130 mein confiscation karke Rs 12,79,878 ki demand confirm hui; dealer se DRC-03 bhi bharwa liya gaya.
- Stock ka weighment nahi hua tha β sirf aankh se andaza aur bag count; department ki apni sheets mein galtiyan thi.
- Dealer regular GSTR-1 aur 3B file karta tha β evasion ka intention prove nahi hua.
- Allahabad HC (Vijay Trading, PP Polyplast, SC ne SLP dismiss ki): sirf excess stock par Section 130 nahi; tax Section 73/74 se hi tay hoga.
π² Sawal hai? WhatsApp karein: 8051331315
Facts
During an inspection on 16.05.2025, officers alleged excess stock at the premises of M/s Poorvi Enterprises valued at Rs 35,55,215. The Deputy Commissioner, SIB, by order dated 26.07.2025, ordered confiscation under Section 130 and confirmed a demand of Rs 12,79,877.96. The dealer had deposited about the same amount through DRC-03 on 17.05.2025. The first appellate authority, by order dated 04.10.2025, set aside the confiscation. The department appealed, also arguing that the monetary limit in Circular 207/01/2024-GST did not apply.
Issue
Whether excess stock detected during inspection, without proof of intent to evade tax, justifies confiscation and penalty under Section 130.
Held / Ruling
- The stock was computed by visual estimation and approximate bag counts, not physical weighment, and the department's own verification sheets were internally inconsistent; they had no evidentiary value.
- No independent evidence β parallel invoices, clandestine production, hidden transport records β supported the allegation that books were manipulated after the survey.
- Confiscation under Section 130 is an extraordinary power requiring proof of deliberate contravention with intent to evade tax. A stock discrepancy alone does not prove it, and Section 130 cannot be chosen merely to collect higher fines.
- Following Vijay Trading Company and PP Polyplast (Allahabad HC, SLPs dismissed by the Supreme Court in 2025), the liability must be determined under Section 73 or 74. Departmental appeal dismissed.
Key takeaways for taxpayers
- Insist on actual weighment during stock verification and sign sheets only after recording your objections.
- A DRC-03 deposit made under pressure during inspection is not an admission of evasion.
- Excess stock can at most lead to Section 73/74 proceedings, not Section 130 confiscation.
Facing a Section 130 confiscation or SIB survey? See our GST litigation services or contact us.