📞 +91 80513 31315 ✉️ gstfolio@zohomail.in 🕘 Monday to Saturday, 10:00 am – 7:00 pm
Home › Blog › GSTAT Lucknow: Delayed Book Entry of Genuine Stock Not Ground for Sec…

GSTAT Lucknow: Delayed Book Entry of Genuine Stock Not Ground for Section 130 Confiscation - Time Steels

Update dated 3 November 2026: The GST Appellate Tribunal, State Bench Lucknow (Court I), in Appeal No. APL/103/LCK/2026 (Revenue vs M/s Time Steels, Lucknow), by order dated 24 October 2026, dismissed the Department's appeal and upheld the deletion of a Section 130 confiscation demand of Rs 1,89,000 raised on a stock difference found during an SIB survey.

🗣️ Saral bhasha mein samjhein

  • SIB survey (20.03.2018) mein physical stock aur books mein farq mila, to department ne Section 130 mein confiscation laga diya – tax Rs 63,000 + penalty Rs 63,000 + redemption fine Rs 63,000.
  • Accountant 2 din chhutti par tha, isliye entries late hui thi; invoice 19.03.2018 ka pehle se bana tha aur GSTR-1/3B mein bhi dikhaya gaya tha.
  • Tribunal ne kaha – genuine transaction ki late entry "unaccounted goods" nahi hoti; Section 130 sirf deliberate evasion ke liye hai.
  • Survey team ne aankh se andaza lagaya tha, proper weighment nahi kiya – ye bhi taxpayer ke favour mein gaya.
  • Department ek hi stock ko Section 74 mein reconcilable aur Section 130 mein confiscable dono nahi bata sakta.

📲 Sawal hai? WhatsApp karein: 8051331315

Facts

M/s Time Steels manufactures and trades M.S. wire, flats and related steel items. During an SIB survey on 20 March 2018, officers compared physical stock with the books and alleged a discrepancy. The goods were detained and a show cause notice under Section 130 read with Section 122 was issued, valuing the goods at Rs 3,50,000 and proposing tax, penalty and redemption fine of Rs 63,000 each. The adjudicating officer confirmed the demand. The first appellate authority set it aside on 13 April 2022, and the Revenue appealed to GSTAT.

Issue

Whether a short delay in recording genuine transactions in the books, caused by the accountant's absence, amounts to failure to account for goods under Section 130(1)(ii) of the CGST/UPGST Act.

Arguments

The Revenue argued that Section 130 is a standalone provision, that liability arises the moment goods are not recorded at the time of survey, that intent is irrelevant, and that later invoices and returns cannot change the position found on the spot. The taxpayer showed that books were complete up to 17 March 2018, the accountant was on leave from 18 to 20 March, a purchase invoice for 9.56 MT dated 19 March 2018 existed before the survey, and the stock was reported in GSTR-1 and GSTR-3B. It also relied on the Supreme Court ruling in Dinesh Kumar Pradeep Kumar that a stock variance found in a survey belongs in Section 73/74 proceedings, not Section 130.

Held / Ruling

  • There is a clear difference between a delayed entry of a genuine transaction and an unaccounted transaction meant for clandestine removal. Delayed bookkeeping backed by regular invoices is not an offence under Section 130.
  • The survey relied on visual approximations instead of proper physical weighment.
  • In separate Section 74 proceedings on the same survey, the officer accepted most explanations and limited the dispute to a minor variance of 1.750 MT. The Department cannot treat the same stock as a reconcilable variance under Section 74 and as confiscable under Section 130.
  • The Revenue's appeal was dismissed and the order deleting the Rs 1,89,000 demand was upheld.

Key takeaways for taxpayers

  • Keep purchase invoices, e-way bills and return filings ready to show that "excess" stock is genuine and recorded.
  • Insist on actual weighment during a survey and record any objection to estimated quantities.
  • A stock difference found at your premises should normally be handled under Section 73/74, not confiscation under Section 130.
  • Use findings of parallel Section 74 proceedings in your favour where they accept your explanation.

Facing a survey, detention or Section 130 notice? Our team handles GST appeals before the appellate authority and GSTAT – see GST litigation services or contact us.

Need help? Call/WhatsApp +91 80513 31315 or email gstfolio@zohomail.in.

Need help with GST or Income Tax?

Registration, monthly returns, ITR and GST notices, handled online by experts since 2012.