Update dated 19 November 2026: The GST Appellate Tribunal, Ernakulam Bench, in Appeal No. APL/44/ERN/2026 (M/s Super Teck Industries vs Commissioner of State GST, Thiruvananthapuram), by Final Order No. 25/EKM/KERALAM/2026 dated 13 November 2026, set aside a Section 129 penalty imposed only because the consignment was not accompanied by an e-invoice, when a proper tax invoice and valid e-way bill were carried.
🗣️ Saral bhasha mein samjhein
- Coimbatore ki firm ne 200 open-well pumps Kochi bheje – tax invoice aur valid e-way bill saath tha.
- Walayar check-post par gaadi roki; maal aur documents mein koi fark nahi, sirf e-invoice (IRN/QR) nahi tha.
- E-invoice agle din bana diya gaya; poora tax aur returns bhi file.
- Tribunal: sirf e-invoice na hone par Section 129 penalty nahi lagti; ye audit/scrutiny mein dekhne wali baat hai.
- Kerala officer ne Tamil Nadu ke dealer ko bina TEMP ID ke MOV-07/MOV-09 diye – jurisdiction hi nahi. Orders void.
📲 Sawal hai? WhatsApp karein: 8051331315
Facts
Super Teck Industries, Coimbatore, supplied 200 Crompton open-well pumps to Crompton Greaves Consumer Electronics, Kochi, under a tax invoice and e-way bill dated 10.02.2021. The vehicle was intercepted at Walayar on 11.02.2021. MOV-04 recorded no discrepancy in goods or documents; the only lapse was absence of an e-invoice, which was mandatory for the supplier's turnover above Rs 100 crore under Rule 48(4) and Notification No. 88/2020-CT. The goods were detained, released on bond, and penalty was imposed by MOV-09 dated 16.04.2021. A Kerala TEMP ID was issued months later. The JC (Appeals), Palakkad upheld the penalty on 30.12.2021.
Issues
- Whether a Kerala officer could issue MOV-07 and MOV-09 to a Tamil Nadu registered person without a TEMP ID.
- Whether Section 129 penalty applies where only the e-invoice is missing.
Held / Ruling
- The Assistant State Tax Officer had no jurisdiction to issue notice or impose penalty on a person outside the State without first issuing a TEMP ID; issuing it months after MOV-07 and MOV-09 was illegal, making those orders void ab initio.
- Rule 138A did not require the e-invoice to accompany goods where a tax invoice and e-way bill were carried; following the Allahabad HC, without a finding of intent to evade, Section 129 cannot be invoked for a technical lapse.
- Any omission under Rule 48 is for the jurisdictional officer to address in audit, scrutiny or assessment. Order-in-appeal set aside with consequential relief.
Key takeaways for taxpayers
- Generate e-invoices before dispatch if your turnover crosses the threshold – but a missing IRN alone does not justify detention penalty when invoice and e-way bill are in order.
- For inter-State interceptions, check whether the officer issued a TEMP ID before passing orders.
Goods detained or penalised in transit? See our GST litigation services or contact us.