Update dated 19 November 2026: The Rajasthan High Court (Jaipur Bench), in D.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 18970/2025 (Jaipur Development Authority vs Additional Commissioner, CGST Audit, Jaipur), by judgment dated 4 November 2026, quashed a Section 74 show cause notice issued after audit, holding that the jurisdictional fact of intent to evade tax was absent.
🗣️ Saral bhasha mein samjhein
- JDA ka FY 2019-20 se 2023-24 ka audit hua; betterment levy, additional FAR charges jaisi receipts par GST maangte hue Section 74 notice (30.09.2025) aaya.
- High Court: Section 74 ke liye fraud/suppression ke saath "to evade tax" – evasion ka intention – alag se dikhana zaroori hai.
- Sirf tax na bharna dono Section 73 aur 74 ka starting point hai; isse intent sabit nahi hota.
- Receipts JDA ki apni books mein the, chhupaye nahi; issue ek legal dispute hai (Article 243W, Section 7).
- Notice aur saari proceedings quash. Department chahe to Section 73 ke dayre mein soch sakta hai.
📲 Sawal hai? WhatsApp karein: 8051331315
Facts
Jaipur Development Authority, a statutory authority under the JDA Act, 1982, was audited under Section 65 for FY 2019-20 to 2023-24. An audit memo dated 30.08.2025 raised 16 observations, followed by a Section 74 notice dated 30.09.2025 proposing tax, interest and penalty on receipts such as betterment levy and additional FAR charges. An earlier DGGI matter on reverse charge on guarantee commission is separately pending in appeal.
Issue
Whether a Section 74 notice is valid where the record discloses no intent to evade tax.
Held / Ruling
- Explanation 2 to Section 74 defines "suppression" but does not dispense with the separate requirement that it be "to evade tax". Any other reading would erase the line between Sections 73 and 74.
- Failure to pay is the starting point of both sections; if it alone proved intent, Section 73 would have no field. The notice showed nothing more.
- The dispute – whether betterment levy and FAR charges are consideration for a supply – is a disagreement on law. The receipts were recorded in JDA's books, an advance ruling in a similar matter supports JDA's view, and its stand rests on Article 243W and Section 7.
- Officers of a public authority gain nothing from evasion; Section 132 also builds in the idea of benefit. The notice lacked the jurisdictional fact and was quashed. The court suggested resolving inter-governmental disputes through the 2018 DPE mechanism, as an observation.
Key takeaways for taxpayers
- A Section 74 notice must show facts proving intent to evade – not merely non-payment or an interpretational dispute.
- Where the transactions are recorded in your books and found in audit, argue there was no suppression.
- A Section 74 notice without the jurisdictional fact can be challenged directly in writ.
Received a Section 74 notice after audit? See our GST litigation services or contact us.