📞 +91 80513 31315 ✉️ gstfolio@zohomail.in 🕘 Monday to Saturday, 10:00 am – 7:00 pm
Home › Blog › GSTAT Bengaluru: Demand Without Show Cause Notice, Only DRC-01 Summar…

GSTAT Bengaluru: Demand Without Show Cause Notice, Only DRC-01 Summary, Quashed - Fortinet Office Meals RCM

Update dated 3 November 2026: The GST Appellate Tribunal, State Bench Bengaluru (Division Bench, Court III), in Appeal No. APL/88/BUR/2026 (Fortinet Technologies India Pvt Ltd vs Commissioner of Commercial Taxes, Karnataka), by final order dated 27 October 2026, set aside an RCM demand on office meal expenses. Only a DRC-01 summary had been issued, with no show cause notice.

🗣️ Saral bhasha mein samjhein

  • FY 2017-18 ke audit ke baad "office meals" ke 2 ledger heads par RCM demand – CGST Rs 1,09,815 + SGST Rs 1,09,815, interest aur 10% penalty ke saath.
  • Section 73(1) ka proper SCN diya hi nahi gaya, sirf DRC-01 summary bheji gayi aur order summarily pass ho gaya.
  • First appellate authority ne naye grounds (unregistered caterer, employees se meal recovery) par demand confirm kar diya – Tribunal ne kaha naye grounds par bina notice demand nahi chal sakta.
  • Outdoor catering Section 9(3) mein notified hi nahi hai; Section 9(4) sirf 01.07.2017 – 12.10.2017 tak tha, wo bhi Rs 5,000/day exemption ke saath.
  • Pre-deposit interest ke saath refund hoga.

📲 Sawal hai? WhatsApp karein: 8051331315

Facts

Fortinet develops network security software and exports IT services. A state GST audit of FY 2017-18 raised four observations. One was non-payment of RCM under Section 9(3) on hiring charges, loan documentation charges and similar expenses. Out of 19 expense heads, 17 were dropped. Two "office meals" heads were retained because the auditor believed amounts were recovered from employees. The proper officer then issued only a summary in Form GST DRC-01 and confirmed the demand. The Joint Commissioner (Appeals) upheld it on 27 June 2025 on the ground of an unregistered outdoor caterer, and alternatively because meal charges were collected from employees.

Issue

Whether a demand can stand where no show cause notice under Section 73(1) was issued, no hearing was given, and the appellate authority confirmed it on new grounds. Also, whether office meal expenses attracted RCM at all.

Arguments

The appellant argued denial of natural justice. It said a DRC-01 summary is not a notice, and that it had explained the Section 9(3)/9(4) distinction with documents. The Revenue relied on the audit findings and the appellate order.

Held / Ruling

  • Serving only a DRC-01 summary, without a notice setting out the grounds, denied the appellant a fair hearing. Its reply was never considered.
  • The first appellate authority could not confirm the demand on a legal basis never put to the appellant. A point raised in defence does not become a charge.
  • Audit findings do not create a confirmed demand unless liability is determined under Section 73 or 74. Tax cannot be levied on assumptions without identifying the supply, value and correct provision.
  • For the period before the Karnataka RFN circular of 23.05.2023, the Tribunal did not treat the absence of a DIN/RFN as invalidating the documents.
  • The demand, interest and penalty were set aside, with refund of any pre-deposit with interest.

Key takeaways for taxpayers

  • A DRC-01 summary alone is not a valid show cause notice. Check whether a proper notice with grounds was issued.
  • If the appellate authority confirms a demand on a new ground, challenge it as beyond the notice.
  • For RCM disputes in 2017-18, check the exact notified service under Section 9(3) and the Section 9(4) window.

Need help with an audit-based demand? See our GST litigation services or contact us.

Need help? Call/WhatsApp +91 80513 31315 or email gstfolio@zohomail.in.

Need help with GST or Income Tax?

Registration, monthly returns, ITR and GST notices, handled online by experts since 2012.