šŸ“ž +91 80513 31315 āœ‰ļø gstfolio@zohomail.in šŸ•˜ Monday to Saturday, 10:00 am – 7:00 pm
Home › Blog › GSTAT Lucknow: Provisional ITC Reversal During Investigation Is Not S…

GSTAT Lucknow: Provisional ITC Reversal During Investigation Is Not Self-Assessed Tax, Rs 14.35 Crore Refund Upheld - B.L. Agro

Update dated 3 November 2026: The GST Appellate Tribunal, State Bench Lucknow (Court I), in Appeal No. APL/53/LCK/2026 (CGST Department vs M/s B.L. Agro Industries Ltd, Bareilly), by order dated 22 October 2026, dismissed the Department's appeal and upheld the order allowing refund of Rs 14.35 crore of ITC provisionally reversed in GSTR-3B.

šŸ—£ļø Saral bhasha mein samjhein

  • Income Tax search (Oct 2018) mein stock shortage ka aarop aaya, to company ne safety ke liye Rs 14.35 crore ITC (CGST + SGST Rs 7.175 crore each) GSTR-3B mein provisionally reverse kar diya.
  • Saath hi 08.10.2018 ko letter likh kar bataya ki ye reversal provisional hai aur refund/restoration ka haq reserve hai.
  • Department ne refund reject kiya – "voluntary reversal = self-assessed tax". Tribunal ne ye nahi maana.
  • Pending investigation se tax liability tay nahi hoti; baad ka demand order (23.12.2025) appeal mein hai, isliye refund rokne ka aadhar nahi.
  • Refund ab bhi Section 54 ki shartein poori hone par hi milega.

šŸ“² Sawal hai? WhatsApp karein: 8051331315

Facts

B.L. Agro Industries manufactures edible oils. During an Income Tax search in October 2018, a stock shortage was alleged. The company informed the GST authorities by letter dated 8 October 2018 that it had reversed ITC of Rs 14.35 crore in its August 2018 GSTR-3B as a provisional measure, pending ascertainment of facts. Years later the Income Tax Department reported book stock of Rs 406.86 crore against physical stock of Rs 119.60 crore. The company's refund claim for the reversed amount was rejected. The Additional Commissioner (Appeals), Noida set aside the rejection on 2 September 2025, and the Department appealed.

Issue

Whether a provisional ITC reversal in GSTR-3B, made during a pending investigation, is a self-assessed tax liability that bars refund.

Arguments

The Department said the reversal was voluntary and part of self-assessment. It said the stock shortage pointed to clandestine removal and that a later Order-in-Original dated 23.12.2025 confirmed a demand of about Rs 14.36 crore. It also said refund was premature while the investigation was pending. The taxpayer relied on its letter of 8 October 2018. It pointed out that the later demand was under appeal, and that third-party stock information is only an investigative lead.

Held / Ruling

  • The letter of 8 October 2018 and the GSTR-3B entries show the reversal was provisional, not an admission of tax payable.
  • A pending investigation is not a determination of liability and cannot justify holding the amount indefinitely.
  • The later Order-in-Original cannot cure the reasoning of the refund rejection. Because it is under appeal, it has not attained finality. Similar amounts (Rs 14.35 crore vs Rs 14.36 crore) do not by themselves prove the reversal discharged that demand.
  • A separate dispute on ITC from a doubted supplier is a different matter and cannot be used to deny this refund.
  • The Department's appeal was dismissed, subject to verification under Section 54.

Key takeaways for taxpayers

  • If you reverse ITC or pay tax "under protest" during an investigation, record in writing at the same time that it is provisional.
  • A pending inquiry alone does not let the Department keep your money. It must determine liability under Section 73/74.
  • Follow the Section 54 time limits and documentation when claiming such refunds.

Refund stuck after a search or investigation? See our GST litigation services or contact us.

Need help? Call/WhatsApp +91 80513 31315 or email gstfolio@zohomail.in.

Need help with GST or Income Tax?

Registration, monthly returns, ITR and GST notices, handled online by experts since 2012.