Update dated 19 November 2026: The GST Appellate Tribunal, Pune Bench, in Appeal No. APL/9/PUN/2026 (M/s Indermal Aidanmal Oswal vs Commissioner of Central Tax, Pune-II), by final order dated 29 October 2026, dismissed the taxpayer's appeal and upheld denial of ITC on a retrospectively cancelled supplier, interest of Rs 3,80,408 on ITC where suppliers were not paid within 180 days, and penalty of Rs 20,000.
š£ļø Saral bhasha mein samjhein
- Ye case taxpayer ke khilaaf gaya ā isse seekh lena zaroori hai.
- Supplier (Shanmukh Traders) ki registration 03.07.2017 se cancel hui; uske 8 invoices par Rs 31,115 IGST ITC deny hua kyunki invoices, payment proof ya supplier certificate pesh nahi kiye gaye.
- Supplier ko 180 din mein payment nahi kiya, isliye second proviso to Section 16(2) aur Rule 37 ke under Rs 3,80,408 interest payable.
- GSTR-2 operational na hone se ye liability khatam nahi hoti.
- Penalty: CGST Rs 10,000 + SGST Rs 10,000 = IGST mein Rs 20,000 (Section 20 IGST Act ka proviso).
š² Sawal hai? WhatsApp karein: 8051331315
Facts
The appellant, a Pune plywood trader, was audited for 01.07.2017 to 31.03.2020. A Section 73 notice dated 10.03.2023 for 2018-19 proposed (a) recovery of IGST ITC of Rs 31,115 on invoices of a supplier whose registration was cancelled with effect from 03.07.2017, and (b) interest of Rs 3,80,408 on ITC relating to supplies not paid for within 180 days. The appellant did not appear at four hearings; the demand was confirmed. The first appellate authority upheld the demand but reduced penalty to Rs 20,000. The appellant paid Rs 31,115 through DRC-03 on 21.01.2025, without interest.
Issues
- Whether ITC on invoices of a retrospectively cancelled supplier was admissible.
- Whether interest is payable on ITC where the supplier was not paid within 180 days.
- Correct penalty for an IGST demand under Section 73(9).
Held / Ruling
- The burden under Section 155 lies on the person claiming ITC. Without invoices, payment proof or a supplier's certificate, the conditions of Section 16(2) were not shown; denial upheld, with Section 50 interest to be quantified.
- Interest of Rs 3,80,408 is payable under the second proviso to Section 16(2) read with Rule 37(3) as then in force. Non-operation of FORM GSTR-2 does not extinguish the liability; the computation was never disputed.
- Ten per cent of Rs 31,115 is below the Rs 10,000 minimum, so penalty is Rs 10,000 each under the CGST and State Acts, aggregated to Rs 20,000 under the fourth proviso to Section 20 of the IGST Act.
- Appeal dismissed. The officer will adjust the pre-deposit of Rs 39,091 and the DRC-03 payment and communicate any balance.
Key takeaways for taxpayers
- Keep invoices, bank proof and supplier compliance records for every ITC claim ā without them the claim fails under Section 155.
- Track supplier payments: ITC on bills unpaid beyond 180 days must be reversed with interest.
- Never skip personal hearings; an ex-parte record is hard to correct later.
Received an audit objection on ITC or Section 50 interest? See our GST litigation services or contact us.