Update dated 19 November 2026: The GST Appellate Tribunal, State Bench Bengaluru (Court III), in Appeal No. APL/4/BUR/2026 (M/s Sandvik Coromant India Pvt Ltd vs Commissioner of Commercial Taxes, Karnataka), by final order dated 14 October 2026, partly allowed the appeal for FY 2019-20, cutting a disputed tax demand of Rs 33.42 lakh down to Rs 51,255.
🗣️ Saral bhasha mein samjhein
- FY 2019-20 ke e-audit mein 4 issues par demand bani thi – kul disputed tax Rs 33,41,760.
- GSTR-2A vs 3B mismatch Rs 3,96,226: Rs 3,44,974 hata diya, sirf Rs 51,255 confirm (interest Rule 88B ke saath aur Section 73(9) penalty).
- "Unaccounted inward supply" par tax ki demand poori set aside.
- Purchase return par ITC reversal mein deri – Rs 27,530 KGST interest aur penalty set aside; 14.03.2024 ko bhara tax adjust.
- GSTR-1 mein credit notes report na karne par Rs 99,718 ki demand, interest aur penalty sab set aside.
📲 Sawal hai? WhatsApp karein: 8051331315
Facts
Sandvik Coromant India Pvt Ltd (formerly Sandvik Asia Pvt Ltd) faced an adjudication order dated 29.06.2024 under Section 73(9) following e-audit for April 2019 to March 2020. The order raised four issues: excess ITC due to a GSTR-2A/3B difference, tax on alleged unaccounted inward supplies, interest on delayed reversal of ITC on purchase returns, and tax on credit notes not reported in GSTR-1. The Joint Commissioner (Appeals-I), Bengaluru upheld the order on 26.11.2025 without dealing with the appellant's submissions.
Issues
- How much of the GSTR-2A/3B difference was genuine excess ITC.
- Whether tax could be demanded on "unaccounted inward supply turnover".
- Whether interest and penalty apply to delayed reversal on purchase returns, and tax on credit notes missing from GSTR-1.
Held / Ruling
- The first appellate order brushed aside the appellant's submissions without reasons.
- Of the ITC disallowance of Rs 3,96,226, Rs 3,44,974 (IGST Rs 95,588, CGST and SGST Rs 1,24,693 each) was set aside; Rs 51,255 was confirmed with interest under Section 50(3) read with Rule 88B and penalty under Section 73(9).
- The demand on unaccounted inward supply turnover was set aside with interest.
- Interest of Rs 27,530 (KGST) and penalty on non-reversal of ITC on purchase returns were set aside; tax paid on 14.03.2024 was appropriated.
- The demand of Rs 99,718 for credit notes not reported in GSTR-1 was set aside with interest and penalty.
Key takeaways for taxpayers
- Reconcile 2A/3B differences invoice by invoice – most "excess ITC" usually disappears on reconciliation.
- Where credit notes or purchase returns are properly documented, a reporting gap in GSTR-1 alone does not create a tax demand.
- Interest under Section 50(3) is payable only on ITC actually wrongly availed and utilised (Rule 88B).
Received an e-audit or 2A/3B mismatch demand? See our GST litigation services or contact us.